In 2020, Starmer’s tweet resonated deeply with many who felt abandoned by a decade of austerity and a draconian welfare system. His words were a rallying cry for a fairer and more humane approach to social security, promising to abolish the cruel two-child limit. This policy, introduced by the Conservatives, has been widely condemned for pushing families into poverty, penalizing them for having more than two children. Yet, despite the clear moral imperative and his own previous commitments, Starmer has now backtracked, stating that Labour will not reverse this policy.

The reaction to Starmer’s reversal has been swift and fierce. Labour MP Zarah Sultana encapsulated the widespread sentiment by condemning the two-child limit as “unspeakably cruel”, highlighting its devastating impact on children and families. Campaigners who once saw Starmer as a potential ally now view his shift as a profound betrayal. This decision undermines the very foundation of his leadership bid, which was built on the promise of compassion and reform.

Starmer’s change in stance is not just a political maneuver; it represents a fundamental shift away from the values he professed to champion. It calls into question his commitment to social justice and the welfare of the most vulnerable in society. This about-face is not just a disappointment but a stark illustration of the gap between political rhetoric and action.

Keir Starmer’s refusal to end the two-child limit is a glaring contradiction of his earlier pledges and a betrayal of those who believed in his vision for a more equitable Britain. This decision exposes a troubling willingness to abandon principles for political expediency, casting doubt on his leadership and his party’s direction, as this has also happened with the abolition of Universal Credit pledge.

SOURCES

1st Video: Keir Starmer Tweet (February 6, 2020) https://x.com/Keir_Starmer/status/1225465424092987393

2nd Video: Keir Starmer confirms to Laura Kuenssberg that Labour will keep the Tory Two-Child Cap - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-NceKCkZ3I

3. Starmer: Labour won't be able to afford to scrap two-child benefit cap - https://youtu.be/04sy3wkZZQw?si=zBy0ZlvcwG9D2oa2

4. Labour would keep two-child benefit cap, says Keir Starmer - https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/jul/16/labour-keep-two-child-benefit-cap-says-keir-starmer